On a radial feeder, three relays sit in series — one at each bus — and all three see the same fault current when a fault occurs at the far end. The art of grading is to make the nearest relay trip first, and the ones behind it wait long enough to act only as backup. This post works through a complete numerical grading calculation for an 11 kV radial feeder with IEC standard inverse IDMT relays, step by step, with every number checked.
Given data
- Source at Bus 1: V = 11 kV, short-circuit capacity Ssc = 150 MVA.
- Line impedances: section 1–2, Z1-2 = 0.6 Ω; section 2–3, Z2-3 = 0.4 Ω.
- Maximum load currents: relay C (Bus 3) 150 A, relay B (Bus 2) 300 A, relay A (Bus 1) 400 A.
- Relays: standard IEC normal inverse IDMT, t = 0.14 × TMS / (PSM0.02 − 1), plug setting PS = 100% (5 A secondary).
- CT ratios: CTC = 150/5 A, CTB = 300/5 A, CTA = 400/5 A.
- Settings: TMSC = 0.1 (minimum time setting at relay C); grading margin Δt = 0.4 s.
Feeder layout and time-current curves
Figure 4(c): Radial feeder layout and graded IDMT curves. Relay C trips fastest; A and B are graded 0.4 s behind. (Diagram redrawn for this post.)
Step 1 — Source impedance and fault currents at each bus
Source impedance at the 11 kV bus:
Zs = V² / Ssc = 11² / 150 = 121 / 150 = 0.8067 Ω
Fault current at Bus 3 (seen by relay C, backed up by B): total impedance Z = 0.8067 + 0.6 + 0.4 = 1.8067 Ω.
If3 = 11,000 / (√3 × 1.8067) = 6,350.85 / 1.8067 = 3,515.2 A
Fault current at Bus 2 (seen by relay B, backed up by A): total impedance Z = 0.8067 + 0.6 = 1.4067 Ω.
If2 = 11,000 / (√3 × 1.4067) = 6,350.85 / 1.4067 = 4,514.7 A
Fault current at Bus 1 (seen by relay A):
If1 = Ssc / (√3 × V) = 150 × 106 / (√3 × 11,000) = 7,873.0 A
Step 2 — Relay C (Bus 3, CT 150/5, pickup 150 A, TMS = 0.1)
For a fault at Bus 3: PSMC = 3,515.2 / 150 = 23.43.
tC = (0.14 × 0.1) / (23.430.02 − 1) = 0.014 / (1.06515 − 1) = 0.014 / 0.06515 = 0.215 s
Step 3 — Relay B (Bus 2, CT 300/5, pickup 300 A)
Required backup time for a fault at Bus 3: tB = tC + Δt = 0.215 + 0.40 = 0.615 s.
At If3 = 3,515.2 A, PSMB = 3,515.2 / 300 = 11.72. Standard (TMS = 1.0) time: t1.0 = 0.14 / (11.720.02 − 1) = 0.14 / 0.05044 = 2.775 s.
TMSB = 0.615 / 2.775 = 0.222
Primary operating time of relay B for a fault at Bus 2 (If2 = 4,514.7 A): PSMB = 4,514.7 / 300 = 15.05.
tB = (0.14 × 0.222) / (15.050.02 − 1) = 0.03108 / 0.0557 = 0.558 s
Step 4 — Relay A (Bus 1, CT 400/5, pickup 400 A)
Required backup time for a fault at Bus 2: tA = tB + Δt = 0.558 + 0.40 = 0.958 s.
At If2 = 4,514.7 A, PSMA = 4,514.7 / 400 = 11.29. Standard (TMS = 1.0) time: t1.0 = 0.14 / (11.290.02 − 1) = 0.14 / 0.04967 = 2.818 s.
TMSA = 0.958 / 2.818 = 0.34
Primary operating time of relay A for a fault at Bus 1 (If1 = 7,873.0 A): PSMA = 7,873.0 / 400 = 19.68.
tA = (0.14 × 0.34) / (19.680.02 − 1) = 0.0476 / 0.0614 = 0.775 s
Summary of results
| Relay (location) | Load current | CT ratio (PS 100%) | Fault current at local bus | PSM at local bus | TMS | Primary trip time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Relay C (Bus 3) | 150 A | 150/5 A | 3,515.2 A | 23.43 | 0.10 | 0.215 s |
| Relay B (Bus 2) | 300 A | 300/5 A | 4,514.7 A | 15.05 | 0.222 | 0.558 s (0.615 s at Bus 3) |
| Relay A (Bus 1) | 400 A | 400/5 A | 7,873.0 A | 19.68 | 0.34 | 0.775 s (0.958 s at Bus 2) |
Check the grading: for a fault at Bus 3, C trips in 0.215 s and B waits until 0.615 s — exactly the 0.4 s margin. For a fault at Bus 2, B trips in 0.558 s and A waits until 0.958 s — again exactly 0.4 s. The grading holds at every bus, so only the nearest breaker opens for any fault on the feeder.
Key points to remember
- Source impedance Zs = V²/Ssc = 0.8067 Ω; fault currents fall as line impedance adds up: 7,873 A at Bus 1, 4,514.7 A at Bus 2, 3,515.2 A at Bus 3.
- Each upstream relay's TMS is set so its backup time is exactly the downstream time plus the 0.4 s grading margin.
- Final settings: TMSC = 0.10, TMSB = 0.222, TMSA = 0.34.
- Primary trip times: C 0.215 s, B 0.558 s, A 0.775 s — the feeder clears any fault from the nearest relay first.
Based on Power System Protection & Switchgear.
