A directional overcurrent relay (67) is clever: it trips only when fault power flows in the forward direction, so it can protect parallel feeders and ring mains without blacking out healthy sections. But it has a blind spot — a small zone right in front of itself where it cannot see a fault at all. That blind spot is called the dead zone, and it appears exactly where the fault is most severe: a close-in three-phase short circuit. This post explains why it happens and the two standard ways to overcome it.
Why the dead zone exists
The driving torque of a directional relay is:
T = K · V · I · cos(θ − Ï„) − Ks
The torque needs voltage as well as current. To close its trip contacts, the relay requires a minimum polarising voltage Vmin — typically 1% to 2% of rated PT voltage. When a solid three-phase short circuit occurs immediately adjacent to the relay and PT location (a close-in bus fault), the voltage at the relay bus collapses to zero (V ≈ 0). Consequently, even though the fault current I is enormous, the directional driving torque becomes:
T = K · (0) · I · cos(θ − Ï„) = 0
The relay fails to operate. This small unprotected section right in front of the relay is called the dead zone.
Voltage collapse and the torque curve
Figure 5(a): Voltage collapse during a close-in 3-phase fault creating a directional relay dead zone. (Diagram redrawn for this post.)
Worked example: how small is Vmin?
Take a PT with a rated secondary voltage of 110 V. The relay needs a minimum polarising voltage of 1–2% of rated voltage:
Vmin = 1% × 110 = 1.1 V to Vmin = 2% × 110 = 2.2 V
Only 1.1–2.2 V of polarising voltage is enough for the relay to develop torque — but a solid close-in three-phase fault drives the bus voltage to practically 0 V, below even that tiny threshold. The current may be 20 times rated, yet with V ≈ 0 the torque is ≈ 0 and the relay sits still. That is why the dead zone is so dangerous: the bigger the fault, the more completely the voltage collapses.
How to overcome the dead zone
| Method | How it works | Covers |
|---|---|---|
| 1. 90° quadrature connection | Use the healthy line-to-line voltage VBC for phase-A current IA. At least one phase voltage remains non-zero during all L–G, L–L and L–L–G close-in faults, so the relay always has a polarising voltage. | Unbalanced faults (L–G, L–L, L–L–G). |
| 2. Voltage memory circuit | Use a resonant L–C tank circuit (in electromechanical / static relays) or a digital ring-buffer storing 2–3 pre-fault voltage cycles (in numerical relays) to sustain the polarising voltage reference long enough after fault inception for the relay to trip. | Three-phase close-in faults, where all three voltages collapse together. |
The quadrature connection fixes the problem for unbalanced faults, because a healthy phase still has voltage. But a solid three-phase fault collapses all three voltages at once — only a memory circuit, which remembers what the voltage looked like a cycle or two before the fault, can keep the relay polarised long enough to trip.
Key points to remember
- Directional torque T = K·V·I·cos(θ − Ï„) needs voltage: below Vmin (1–2% of rated PT voltage) there is no torque.
- A close-in 3-phase fault collapses the bus voltage to ≈ 0, so the relay fails even with enormous fault current — that is the dead zone.
- The 90° quadrature connection (VBC for IA) cures the dead zone for unbalanced faults.
- A voltage memory circuit (L–C tank or digital ring-buffer of 2–3 pre-fault cycles) cures it for 3-phase close-in faults.
Based on Power System Protection & Switchgear.
